Market analysis · 16 November 2026
Iceland's insurance market: strong underwriting, weak investments, and banks at the door
Four companies write nearly all Icelandic insurance. In 2025 every one of them made money on underwriting, most of them lost ground on investments, and the third of the four ended up owned by a bank. This is what the public filings show.
The short version
- Underwriting is the profit engine. Combined ratios improved everywhere in 2025 and have stayed low through 2026. Sjóvá went from 96.2% to 92.6%; VÍS doubled its insurance result.
- Investment books cut headline profits roughly in half. Sjóvá's net profit fell 51% and Vörður's about 46% in 2025, in a year when their core insurance business got better.
- Distribution is moving into the banks. Landsbankinn bought TM in February 2025 and now sells its policies in the bank's app. Arion already owns Vörður.
- The Competition Authority is the limit on further consolidation. Two large financial mergers touching the sector were abandoned in early 2026.
Who is in the market
Iceland's market is a long-standing oligopoly. In 2004 the competition regulator found that three companies held about 90% between them, and its 2016 estimates still put VÍS, Sjóvá and TM at a quarter to a third of non-life premiums each, with Vörður the smaller fourth. Since then Sjóvá has overtaken VÍS as the largest, and Vörður has grown faster than the market every year since 2017 by its own account.
| Insurer | Owner | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Sjóvá | Listed on Nasdaq Iceland | Largest by insurance revenue. The only one of the four that is neither part of a bank nor of a wider financial group. |
| VÍS | Skagi hf. (listed) | Second largest and growing fastest in 2025. Sits beside the investment bank Fossar and the securities firm Íslensk verðbréf. |
| TM | Landsbankinn, since 28 Feb 2025 | Third largest. Bought from Kvika banki for ISK 32.3bn after years of shrinking non-life market share. |
| Vörður | Arion banki | Smallest of the four, with the lowest combined ratio in 2025. |
Insurance revenue, 2025 (ISK billion)
The growth gap matters. Sjóvá's chief executive attributed its slowest growth in years to "increased competition" and to less new activity among corporate customers. VÍS grew almost three times as fast. At those rates VÍS would be the larger of the two within two years.
Underwriting: a very good two years
The combined ratio is claims plus costs as a share of premiums; under 100% means the insurance business itself is profitable before any investment income. VÍS was at 99.5% as recently as 2023. All four are now well below that.
| Combined ratio | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 so far |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sjóvá | 96.2% | 92.6% | 90.8% (9 months) |
| VÍS | ≈ 95% * | ≈ 90.7% * | 90.4% (first half) |
| TM | n/a | 92.7% † | 89.9% (first half) |
| Vörður | < 90% | 89.8% | 91.4% (9 months) |
* Derived here from Skagi's reported insurance revenue and insurance service result, not a company-reported ratio. † 28 February to 31 December 2025, the period of Landsbankinn's ownership. Sources: 1–6.
The main explanation the companies give is claims: 2025 was light on large losses. Sjóvá booked one, against six major fires in 2024. VÍS reported its lowest half-year combined ratio since 2007 in the first half of 2026.
Vörður is the exception in direction. It still has a healthy ratio, but it rose from 89.0% to 91.4% over the first nine months of 2026 while the other three held steady or improved.
Profits: the investment side took it back
Icelandic insurers hold large portfolios of domestic bonds and equities, so their net profit swings with the local stock market far more than with claims. In 2025 that worked against them.
| 2025 | Insurance result | Return on investments | Net profit | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sjóvá | ISK 2.6bn | 3.7% (2024: 9.4%) | ISK 2.1bn | −51% |
| Skagi (VÍS) | ISK 3.0bn | 5.2% (target: 10%) | ISK 1.9bn | −16% |
| Vörður | ISK 2.1bn | not disclosed | ≈ ISK 2.0bn | ≈ −46% |
| TM (10 months) | ISK 1.7bn | not disclosed | n/a | n/a |
Insurance result is the pre-tax result from insurance contracts. Skagi's profit is for the whole group. Sources: 1, 2, 3, 4.
Sjóvá is the clearest case: its insurance result doubled to ISK 2.6bn while investment profit collapsed from ISK 3.4bn to ISK 0.4bn, of which a ISK 1.6bn loss came from a single holding, Alvotech. The company plans on an 8.5% long-term return; it earned 3.7% in 2025 and 2.0% in the first nine months of 2026.
The result is an unusual mix for this market: insurers that are earning more from insurance than from investing. That is healthier, but it also means the profits are now visible in the premium, which is where customers and competitors look.
Banks, mergers and the regulator
- VÍS's insurance operations move into a subsidiary, VÍS tryggingar hf., completing Skagi's shift to a holding structure.
- Landsbankinn completes the ISK 32.3bn purchase of TM. The Competition Authority clears it on one condition: the bank may not tie special TM terms to having a salary account at Landsbankinn.
- Íslandsbanki and Skagi sign heads of terms to merge; Skagi's shareholders would get about 15% of the bank.
- Íslandsbanki ends the Skagi talks.
- Arion banki (Vörður's owner) and Kvika banki (TM's former owner) drop their planned merger after the Competition Authority opposes it.
Had the Íslandsbanki deal gone through, each of Iceland's three big banks would have owned one of the four insurers, leaving Sjóvá alone. It did not, and the regulator's stance on the Arion and Kvika deal suggests the bar for further combinations among large financial firms is high.
The one deal that did close is already changing distribution. TM policies are sold in Landsbankinn's app, premiums earn the bank's loyalty points, and TM and the bank now share premises at five locations. TM's insurance result in the first half of 2026 was up more than 50% on a year earlier, although the earlier period only starts on 28 February. The regulator said it expects the new ownership to make TM a more aggressive competitor, which is consistent with what Sjóvá is reporting from the other side.
What sits outside the private market
Iceland has volcanoes, earthquakes and avalanches, but those losses are largely not carried by the four insurers. Catastrophe cover on fire-insured property is provided by a public body, the Natural Catastrophe Insurance of Iceland (NTÍ). This is why the Grindavík eruptions since late 2023 do not show up as a spike in private combined ratios. The private book is mostly motor, property, liability and accident, and life insurance is small: life insurers held ISK 18bn of the sector's ISK 349bn in assets in March 2026.
Insurers are supervised by the Central Bank of Iceland under Solvency II rules. Sjóvá's solvency ratio was 1.40 at the end of 2025.
What to watch in 2027
- Claims returning to normal. Sjóvá expects about 92% for 2026 but guides to 93–95% for the next twelve months, and budgets for two to three large losses a year. Current ratios are better than the companies themselves think is sustainable.
- Price competition. With all four comfortably profitable on underwriting, there is room to compete on price. Sjóvá's slower growth and Vörður's rising ratio are the first signs of who pays for it.
- TM inside Landsbankinn. The first full calendar year under bank ownership is 2026. If bank distribution wins share, expect Arion to push Vörður the same way.
- Skagi on its own. After the failed merger, VÍS targets a combined ratio under 91.5% and remains the most obvious partner if a bank deal becomes possible again.
- Investment returns. Sjóvá's portfolio has now had two weak years in a row. A recovery would lift profits quickly; a third weak year would put dividends under pressure.